Barb Luikkonen, Water Resources Center and Minnesota Sea Grant Program, 612-625-9256
Recent research conducted by Matt Lindon and Steve Heiskary of the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency (MPCA) investigated blue-green algal Cyanobacteria) toxicity in our Minnesota lakes. In Minnesota, accounts of algal toxicity go back to the 1800s, but it seems we’re hearing more about the problem these days.
In 2004, three dog deaths were attributed to algal toxicity, including one on Fish Lake in Kanabec County, and two on Lake Benton in Lincoln County. In 2005, the MPCA joined the state departments of Natural Resources and Health and the Minnesota Veterinary Medicine Association to form the Minnesota Blue-green Algal Toxicity Workgroup. In 2006, a study on Microcystin was conducted on twelve eutrophic (nutrient rich) lakes in south central Minnesota. The study lakes were selected based on a history of high algal levels.”
Many algae species produce toxins that can have adverse effects on animals, (including humans). Probably the most studied algal toxin is Microcystin (MC). MC, a hepatoxin (relating to liver damage) is produced by several bluegreen species including: Microsystis, anabaena, planktohrix, nostoc, and hapalo-siphon, and some other algal species. Some algae, such as anabaena, also produce neurotoxins like anatoxin and saxitoxin. The type and amount of toxins produced can also vary among different strains of toxin producing species.
Currently there are no guidelines or standards for Microcystin levels in Minnesota lakes. The World Health Organization (WHO) has set a standard for drinking water of <1 ppb and these standards for recreational exposure:
- Level 1: 4 ppb (avoid bathing, emerging head, or ingestion)
- Level 2: 20 ppb (avoid visible scums or strong green color)
- Level 3: Surface scum (avoid spray, wear protective clothing)
For this study, researchers used the following Risk Categories: 1 ppb MC = Very Low (below drinking water guideline), 1-10 = Low; 10-20 = Moderate; 20-2000 = High; >2000 = Very High.
They studied 12 eutrophic or hypereutrophic lakes in south central Minnesota during the summer of 2006, sampling six times from May to September. They sampled twice on each lake: once at a mid-lake “pelagic” site for which they ran a full water chemistry analysis and MC; and at a second site near shore where they analyzed for MC and chlorophyll-a.
Their study was designed to address these questions:
- What levels of MC would typically occur in eutrophic/hypereutrophic MN Lakes?
- Would near-shore results differ from pelagic sites?
- How did MC levels vary through the summer?
- What limnological and physical factors appear to be associated with high MC concentrations?
Initial results from their research indicated that there are no strong seasonal patterns evident in these Minnesota lakes, that there was a greater occurrence of high-risk levels at near-shore sites, and that the likelihood of encountering high risk MC levels near shore was increased when there was a surface scum present.
Twenty-five percent of the results (from all lakes, all sample dates) exceeded the WHO low risk category. As algal bloom intensity increased, there was a greater likelihood of encountering high MC values; when chlorophyll-a exceeded 30 ppb (severe nuisance bloom levels) the risk of finding high MC levels increased to ~ 15%. In contrast, at lower bloom levels, (<30 ppb chlorophyll-a), MC was always in the low risk category.
Other limnological factors that appear to be associated with high MC levels include higher pH, higher total suspended volatile solids, higher chlorophyll-a content, and a higher percent of chlorophyll-a from MC producers. As the Secchi disk depth and alkalinity decreased, the likelihood of toxic algal blooms seemed to increase.
In conclusion, MC was detected regularly in these 12 eutrophic lakes in south central Minnesota, and at some concerning levels:
- 94% of the MC results were above the low risk level;
- 25% of the MC results were above the WHO low risk category;
- The likelihood of a moderate to high risk of MC at a near-shore site when scum was present was 25%.
This report, titled Microcystin Levels in Eutrophic South Central Minnesota Lakes, will be posted on the PCA web site later this month.
Questions? Contact Matt Lindon at the MPCA, at Matthew.Lindon@state.mn.us